| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
BlakeB717 |
|||
|
Yeah, I call bull shit on all these idols. Although it does make the season interesting since most of the Galwhos are boring.. but Russ H is just ickyicky
|
|||
A Bartholomew |
|||
|
Russell and Mark Burnett should get OTTNN5 for being cheaters
|
|||
9RedWing19 |
|||
|
You may hate the guy, but finding 2 idols without a single clue either time is commendable. P tone this episode?
Anticipating Warrior's chart, but Russell will likely be 5+ again this episode, so he continues to have a unique edit. That makes the question: if he had won, would they have edited him this way? |
|||
Us Kids Know |
|||
BlakeB717 wrote:MAYBE THAT EXPLAINS WHY EDGIC IS WRONG 9 TIMES OUT OF 10 HMM :c? Ootwatrollite hating this season cements it as one of the best ever <3 ^_^ |
|||
Oowatanite |
|||
BlakeB717 wrote: Interesting ? The preview shows everyone running around for idols. Repeat, for four or five more episodes. Survivor is more rigged than Big Brother. |
|||
WhoLetTheBlTCHout |
|||
|
Posts: 225 (11/12/09 8:05 PM) I don't take hints
|
lol they didn't listen to Monica's strategy
|
||
augustus713 |
|||
|
Boy, I love Russell. What an awesome player.
|
|||
BlakeB717 |
|||
|
Russ H's tone is going to be tough. It's hard to look through the eyes of the editors this season regarding him... I think they want his success to "grow on us" but it's so obvious that he's being told where the idols are!! I want to hand out NNs but... I'm not so sure that was the intent. |
|||
BlakeB717 |
|||
Us Kids Know wrote: I don't know about Edgic before S6 but I know that they got it right in seasons 6, 7, 10, 12, 13, 14, and 16. In the seasons where the majority was wrong, there was still a lot of support for Todd and JT in 15 and 18 respectively. Edgic works. |
|||
BlakeB717 |
|||
|
I'm directing this post strictly to our resident screencappers, flf and Warrior:
Can we get some visuals of the consistent TC shot manipulation of Mick during last week's TC and this week's TC? For someone so hidden he seems to be getting quite a bit of manipulation there (and as we know, that is the most heavily manipulated portion of the show). I would appreciate it! |
|||
MasterDarkNinja |
|||
|
Thoughts during the episode
-Russel & Natalie get credit at finding cracks in Gelu (Russel) & getting votes needed (Natalie). Plan is called Natalie's plan in recap. FoaFoa still called the underdogs by Jeff in recap. -Russel right away says he feels in danger, no hesitation at using the idol, Laura later says that Russell is in danger. -Thought it was interesting how there was no footage of before the merge in the recap, recap focused very heavily on Natalie and Russel. I don't think Mick or Jaison were even mentioned in it. -Wow, Natalie suddenly getting a lot of airtime for no apparent reason...and all of this P SPV about catching a rat. -And Russel finds the HII while the reward winners still aren't back yet, I figured he would. -Shambo shown not wanting to get rid of Russel, no wonder why they showed Shambo & Russel's southern bond last episode -Laura wins immunity again, and Russel wants the Gelu's to vote for him, Shambo thinks they should get rid of Kelly now to weaken Gelu more, we'll see if that happens or not. -Shambo sure aligned herself 100% with Russel and Foa Foa with her earlier confessionals on feeling like a part of Foa Foa for the last 2 weeks, doesn't seem like she'll go back to Gelu with her edit this episode. -If anyone gives Russel a N this episode then they're just giving it by reflex, he had no N scenes, the most N thing was an early confessional by Laura I think about him being dumb playing the idol the previous TC. Russel was the underdog for the first half of the episode, then we were met to root for him and his plan to get rid of a member of Gelu with the HII (with the target being N Laura originally). I think he was P this episode. -For Foa Foa this seemed like a good episode for Natalie & Russel, but not so great of an episode for Mick & Jaison (though certainly not as bad as last episode for Mick). Jaison and Mick mostly just commented on Natalie catching a rat, and Russel telling them about his new HII. -Seems like Russel is closest to Jaison among the Foa Foa's based on who he always tells his plans. That's surprising with how he was dissing him earlier in the season -Erik was cheering for Russel and the Foa Foa's when Russel played his HII, something to keep in mind later. |
|||
SFC |
|||
|
Initial ratings.
Brett INV Dave MOR Jaison MOR John UTR Kelly MORN Laura MOR Mick UTR Monica UTR1 Natalie OTTP Russell CPP (I know hes negative, but this episode, we were supposed to root for him) Shambo MOR |
|||
xfactor99 |
|||
|
Can we nominate Kelly for the worst edit ever? (so far, if Brett gets nothing the rest of the way he'll surpass her)
|
|||
SFC |
|||
xfactor99 wrote: How dare you forget Liliana. |
|||
xfactor99 |
|||
SFC wrote: Yeah, but she was invisible for what, 4 episodes? Kelly had 9 episodes with nothing but INVs and UTR1/2s until this pretty crappy boot edit. |
|||
BlakeB717 |
|||
|
Galu was labelled as "condescending" etc. so should we give a lot of N tones to them or not? I think the only one saved of N tone for sure is Monica
(I KNOW SUPRISE COMING FROM ME) because she was the only one who was shown not underestimating them. I think she had a nasty comment about FoaFoa at the RC
though but I'm not sure. I think N for Laura and Kelly probably, but I'm not sure... what about John and Dave? Associative Ns?
I think the only Ps were Natalie and maybe RussH... Shambo maybe? Not sure. P for Jaison for being proud of Nat and Mick for being the underdog voice (I hope he doesn't turn into Sundra for the sake of his edit.. though I loved her) and both being apart of FoaFoa? Probably not, but I saw a lot of Good VS Evil going on tonight. Quick question, because I missed it: Did Shambo vote for Kelly? |
|||
AndreSurvivor |
|||
|
Posts: 632 (11/12/09 8:27 PM) |
Is Brett still INV if he has that one sub-titled quote post-TC right at the beginning talking about cookies with peanut butter? I *think* it was him.
|
||
Hippochinfat |
|||
SFC wrote: I don't see how Kelly got an N, even Shambo said nobody really has anything against or for Kelly, Shambo was telling us she's neutral. |
|||
McPhever224 |
|||
|
Posts: 381 (11/12/09 8:27 PM) Registered user |
SFC wrote: When was Kelly N? |
||
craig |
|||
I still stand by my pick, though. Natalie winning still wouldn't be Edgic even if she's CPP4 for the rest of the season. RussH isn't edgic either.Mick has become Sierra 2.0. Picking someone with TWO horribly neglected episodes around the merge is not good edgic. Natalie became a fierce huntress this episode, klling a rat with a stick. The Galu's regard her as the 2nd biggest threat next to Russell, so she'd got more social-strategic cred with them than do-nothing Mick. Shambo won a bit of respect when she suggested targting Kelly because the boys have issues with Monica. Shambo hates Laura, doesn't have a personal grudge with the younger girls. We see now that Monica vs Shambo was set up premerge because they are probably the last two Galu standing. If a Galu wins, it's Monica. If only Dave had listened to her fears about a 2nd idol ...
Last Edited By: craig
11/12/09 8:32 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||